Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

3 N.H. 346

Otis v. Hussey

Superior Court of New Hampshire

Decided February 15, 1826

Superior Court of New Hampshire · decided 1826-02-15

Assumpsit upon a promissory note for $15, made by one Stephen Henderson, payable to the defendant, or order, on demand, with interest, and by the defendant indorsed. The cause was tried here, at February term, 1825, upon the general issue ; when it appeared in evidence, that the defendant indorsed the note in blank and delivered it to one Warren, who passed it to the plaintiff, for a valuable consideration.

Cited by 1 later decisions — most recently December 1879

1 state decisions

Relies on Trimble v. Thorne · Duryee v. Dennison · Griffin v. Goff

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1826-02-15

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Richardson, C. J.

¶1delivered the opinion of the court.

¶2It is extremely well settled, that, in general, no action can be maintained by an endorsee, against the endorser of a promissory note, without a demand of the maker. But in same cases the law receives evidence of a diligent inquiry for the maker, without success, as an excuse for the want of a demand. 12 East 433, Bateman vs. Joseph.

¶3In this case there was no direct evidence shewing any diligence on the part of the plaintiff to find the maker, except the inquiries he made, when he received the note ; and those inquiries are clearly insufficient evidence of themselves to shew such diligence, as will excuse the want of a demand. 1 Pick. 413, Shed vs. Prett.

¶4It is also well settled, that a promise to pay, made by the endorser, with a full knowledge, that no demand has been made of the maker, is a waiver of the consequences of the want of demand. Chitt. on bills 172.—12 Mass. Rep. 52, Hopkins vs. Leswell.—5 Johns. 248, Duryee vs. Dennison.

¶5But, to give this effect to a promise, it must appear and be shown affirmatively and clearly, that the promise was made with a full knowledge, that no demand had been made. 1 Cowen 397, Sice vs. Cunningham.—16 Johns. 152, Trimble vs. Thorn.—12 Johns. 423, Griffin vs. Goff.—8 Johns. 384, Craine vs. Colwell.

¶6We are aware, that it has been held in England, that a promise to pay is, in these cases, to be left to a jury, as evidence of a demand. 7 East 231, Lundie vs. Robertson. In an old commercial country, like England, where a great portion of the business has long been transacted by means of negotiable paper, and where most of those, who deal in such paper, must be presumed to be acquainted with the law in re--*348lationto it, it may be proper to leave it to a jury is infer a demand of the maker from a promise of the endorser to pay. But in this state, where negotiable paper has a very limited circulation, there is no ground, on which such ail inference from that fact can rest ; and we are of opinion, that the rule adopted in New-York is the true one. It must be shown affirmatively, that the defendant had notice, when he made the promise, that no demand had been made, and that there had been no attempt to make one. As this was not done in this case, there must be

¶7Judgment on the verdict,

/3/nh/346 · .json · Public domain