Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

3 Sadler 383

Murray v. McCarthy

Supreme Court of Pennsylvania

Decided October 4, 1886

Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · decided 1886-10-04

<p>An absolute conveyance in fee will not be converted into a mortgage by a defeasance executed immediately afterward but not part of the contract for the conveyance.</p> <p>Parol evidence is admissible to rebut the presumption that a defeasance bearing the same date as an absolute deed in fee simple was not part of the contract for the conveyance, but a.n afterthought.</p> <p>Cited in Gattle Bros. v. Kremp, 6 Pa. Super. Ot. 514, 521, 41 W. N. C. 569.</p> <p>Note. — By the act of June 8, 1881 (P. L. 84), a deed absolute on its face cannot be changed by a defeasance into a mortgage, unless by writing executed contemporaneously with the deed. Grove v. Kase, 195 Pa. 325, 45 Atl. 1054. This legislation applies only to deeds. Brown v. Beecher, 120 Pa. 590, 15 Atl. 608; Huston v. Regn, 184 Pa. 419, 39 Atl. 208. Its provisions can be invoked only by parties in interest. Burkhart v. Farmers’ Union Asso. 11 Pa. Super. Ct. 280.</p>

Cited by 1 later decisions — most recently March 1868

1 state decisions

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Affirmed · Decided 1886-10-04

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Per Curiam:

¶1We see no error in the admission of evidence nor in refusing to affirm the points submitted by the plaintiff. The jury have found that the execution of the deed and the giving of the mortgage were not one transaction. The execution of the mortgage was an afterthought. It was after the deed had been delivered.

¶2There is no error in the charge of the court.

¶3Judgment affirmed-

/3/sadler/383 · .json · Public domain