Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

3 Yeates 48

Shaw v. Atkinson

Supreme Court of Pennsylvania

Decided September 15, 1800

Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · decided 1800-09-15

Replevin for goods distrained for rent, brought to December term 1798. Afterwards “all matters in variance between the “parties in this cause were referred to William Hamilton, John “Dunlap and John Dorsey, or any two of them.” The referees reported the sum of 1000 dollars to be-due to the defendants, upon a balance of all accounts, by them settled up to the 1st July 1800.

Decided 1800-09-15

By the Court.

¶1We have every leaning in favour of awards, which so greatly contribute to settle disputes. But here the finding of the referees clearly exceeds their authority, which was confined to rent due on the nth December 1798, for which the distress was taken. A confirmation of the report therefore, would be error on the face of the proceedings. • Besides, the *49bail to the sheriff in the replevin bond might be improperly affected by such a decision. When they became sureties for the plaintiff, they would naturally regard the quantum of rent then claimed by the landlords, and determine their conduct accordingly.

¶2Report set aside.

/3/yeates/48 · .json · Public domain