Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

30 F. Cas. 1073

Dermott v. Fowler

U.S. District Court

Decided September 27, 1853

U.S. District Court · decided 1853-09-27

At law. Action of debt. The declaration states that the defendant was indebted to the plaintiff in the sum of $449.92, for material furnished and work and labor, performed and bestowed on the • party-wall, being the north wall of the warehouse-owned by the plaintiff, and being between the plaintiff and defendant, agreeable to the 4th section of Regulation No. 1, entitled “Terms and conditions declared by president of the United States, the 17th October, 1791, for regulating…

Decided 1853-09-27

¶1On the trial of the case the following remarks were made by THE COURT: We think the jury, in estimating 'the cost of the wall to be paid for by the defendant, may take into consideration such expense as the defendant was necessarily put to to make the part of the wall so used by him fit for that purpose, unless the jury shall find from the evidence that the defendant waived such defects, or those under whom he claims waived them. It must be considered that the defendant, when he purchased, did so with . a view to the condition in which it was at that time, and. whatever damage was done by it. placing the wall there, claimed for in this case, might have risen in relation to the freehold. This defendant cannot have a Tight to recover therefor. There seemed to be a claim for set-off-against-the plaintiff’s account for ground used by the plaintiff, although she denied the claim.

/30/fcas/1073 · .json · Public domain