558
Submitted May 27, reversed and remanded July 22, 2020
DAVID R. DURHAM,
Plaintiff-Appellant,
v.
Garrett LANEY,
Superintendent,
Oregon State Correctional Institution;
R. Briones, Asst. Supt. State Penitentiary;
G. Long, Asst. Supt.
Oregon State Correctional Institution,
Defendants-Respondents.
Marion County Circuit Court
19CV16996; A171270
471 P3d 818
Plaintiff, an inmate currently housed at the Oregon State Correctional
Institution (OSCI), petitioned for a writ of habeas corpus, alleging that defendants have denied him constitutionally adequate medical treatment for his
post-traumatic stress disorder, anxiety, depression, and an uncontrolled bowel
and vomiting condition. Plaintiff alleged that, despite knowing that plaintiff’s
accommodations were deemed medically necessary by multiple medical professionals, defendants suspended all treatment without explanation. Defendants,
the superintendent of OSCI and two other prison officials, moved to deny the
petition on the ground that the petition failed to state a claim for relief, and the
trial court granted the motion. On appeal, plaintiff assigns error to that denial.
Held: The trial court erred. When construed in the light most favorable to plaintiff, as required by the standard of review, the petition alleged that defendants
were aware that plaintiff has serious medical needs and elected not to provide
him with treatment long viewed as necessary and proper, resulting in a significant adverse effect on plaintiff’s daily activities.
Reversed and remanded.
Courtland Geyer, Judge.
Jedediah Peterson and O’Connor Weber LLC filed the
brief for appellant.
Ellen F. Rosenblum, Attorney General, Benjamin Gutman,
Solicitor General, and E. Nani Apo, Assistant Attorney
General, filed the brief for respondents.
Before Lagesen, Presiding Judge, and James, Judge, and
Kamins, Judge.
Cite as 305 Or App 558 (2020) 559
LAGESEN, P. J.
Reversed and remanded.
560 Durham v. Laney
LAGESEN, P. J.
Plaintiff, an inmate currently housed at the Oregon
State Correctional Institution (OSCI), petitioned for a writ
of habeas corpus, alleging that defendants have denied him
constitutionally adequate medical treatment for his post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), anxiety, depression, and
an uncontrolled bowel and vomiting condition. Defendants,
the superintendent of OSCI and two other prison officials,
moved to deny the petition on the ground that the petition
failed to state a claim for relief, and the trial court granted
the motion.1 On appeal, we conclude that plaintiff’s petition
sufficiently states a claim upon which habeas corpus relief
may be granted. Accordingly, we reverse.
We review to determine whether the allegations in
the petition are legally sufficient to state a claim “assuming
the truth of all the allegations in the petition and giving
plaintiff the benefit of all favorable inferences that may be
drawn from them—as we must on a motion to deny.” Taylor
v. Peters, 274 Or App 477, 481,
361 P3d 54 (2015), aff’d,
360
Or 460,
383 P3d 279 (2016). We state the facts in accordance
with that standard, drawing them from the petition and
viewing them in plaintiff’s favor.
According to the petition, plaintiff is a 66-year-old
inmate with physical and psychological disabilities. Before
November 2018, he was incarcerated at the Oregon State
Penitentiary (OSP). There, plaintiff had access to medically
necessary “mental health programs, therapeutic aids, and
services,” which included access to medication for his psychological condition, auxiliary aids (cassette tapes for managing plaintiff’s PTSD), weekly counseling sessions, and
housing in a single cell to accommodate plaintiff’s bowel
and vomiting condition and PTSD. OSP had been addressing plaintiff’s medical needs for over 10 years.
In response to plaintiff’s investigation into OSP’s
suspected interference with its inmates’ legal appeals preparations, plaintiff was transferred to OSCI in November 2018.
Upon his transfer to OSCI, he “was immediately stripped of
1
The trial court adopted the arguments and authority cited in defendants’
motion in explaining its decision.
Cite as 305 Or App 558 (2020) 561
all medications, all physical aids, all psychological servicesprograms, weekly [PTSD] counseling, one on one counseling, [and] single cell living due to phobia of living close to
people.” Instead of a single cell, plaintiff was housed in a
dorm setting with other inmates. One of the aids prescribed
to manage plaintiff’s PTSD is a cassette player with audiotapes, but he was not allowed to have that aid at OSCI. His
first night at OSCI, he “experienced severe medication withdrawal,” requiring emergency medical assistance.
In the days following that incident, OSCI’s Health
Services told plaintiff that all of his medical needs and
accommodations would be reevaluated. An OSCI doctor
informed him that “OSCI does not have the necessities to
provide for [you].” The doctor indicated that he would order
a single cell to accommodate plaintiff’s needs but explained
that that order would require approval from several OSCI
officials. Plaintiff learned several days later that the
requested approval was denied. He sent a detailed list of his
other special needs to Health Services as well, and he never
received a response. Other inmates at OSCI are housed in
single cells and allowed to have audio players.
Since plaintiff’s transfer to OSCI, he has not had
access to his psychological medication or mental health programs. His physical and mental health have deteriorated:
He is “losing the ability to communicate to others” and “is
becoming disoriented.” He suffers from “fear, inability to
sleep, [and inability to] eat,” and OSCI’s psychiatrist has
diagnosed him as “decompensating.” On at least one occasion, plaintiff publicly soiled himself due to OSCI’s refusal
to accommodate his medical conditions. This severely
aggravated plaintiff’s depression to the extent that plaintiff entered “a zombie-state lasting for over a week” leaving plaintiff with “[n]o recollection of anything, complete[ly]
blacked-out.”
On appeal, the issue before us is whether, when construed liberally in plaintiff’s favor, the petition “fails to state
a claim upon which habeas corpus relief may be granted.”
ORS 34.370(7). To state a cognizable claim that a deprivation
of medical care is unconstitutional under Article I, section
16, of the Oregon Constitution and the Eighth Amendment
562 Durham v. Laney
to the United States Constitution, plaintiff was required to
allege facts showing that he “has a serious medical need
that has not been treated in a timely and proper manner
and that prison officials have been deliberately indifferent
to the prisoner’s serious medical needs.” Billings v. Gates,
323 Or 167, 180-81,
916 P2d 291 (1996) (adopting, for purposes of Article I, section 16, the Eighth Amendment standards articulated in Estelle v. Gamble,
429 US 97, 106,
97
S Ct 285,
50 L Ed 2d 251 (1976)).
Beginning with whether plaintiff has sufficiently
alleged that he has a serious medical need, we agree that
he has. “A medical condition is serious when, if untreated, it
would have a significant adverse effect on an inmate’s daily
activities, resulting in substantial and recurring pain or
discomfort, or would create a significant risk of permanent
disability or death.” Billings, 323 Or at 181. Both physical
conditions and mental health conditions can constitute the
type of serious conditions that implicate an inmate’s rights
under Article I, section 16, and the Eighth Amendment.
Villarreal v. Thompson,
142 Or App 29, 32-33,
920 P2d 1108
(1996) (concluding that allegations about the plaintiff’s mental health condition “clearly establish the existence of a serious medical need”). Here, plaintiff alleges that several daily
activities—including eating, sleeping, communicating, and
using the restroom—have been adversely affected by plaintiff’s untreated conditions. And defendants do not appear to
dispute that plaintiff’s medical needs, as alleged, are serious ones for purposes of Article I, section 16, and the Eighth
Amendment.
Plaintiff also sufficiently alleges that those serious
medical needs have “not been treated in a timely and proper
manner.” According to the allegations, OSCI officials simply
stopped treating those needs, in a way that caused plaintiff
to decompensate and suffer other significant health consequences, notwithstanding the facts that plaintiff’s need for
treatment has been established for more than 10 years and
that the needed treatment was provided to plaintiff for more
than 10 years while he was housed at OSP.
Finally, plaintiff has sufficiently alleged facts showing that defendants are being deliberately indifferent to his
Cite as 305 Or App 558 (2020) 563
serious medical needs. According to the petition, when construed liberally in plaintiff’s favor, plaintiff’s treatments
and accommodations were deemed medically necessary by
multiple medical professionals and had been provided to
him for 10 years or more and, although defendants knew
about his medical conditions and the treatment long deemed
necessary, defendants suspended all treatment without any
explanation beyond an assertion that plaintiff’s medical
needs were being reevaluated. These facts, if proved, would
allow the inference that defendants are aware that plaintiff
has serious medical needs and are intentionally electing not
to provide him with treatment long viewed as necessary and
proper.
In arguing for a contrary result, defendants narrowly focus their argument on plaintiff’s allegation that
they have failed to provide him with a single cell. They contend that plaintiff
“alleged only that [defendants] refused to house him in a single cell so that he could ‘manage’ his symptoms—meaning,
presumably, that he could use the restroom whenever he
needed to. That allegation does not state sufficient facts to
allege that the OSCI officials denied or delayed access to
medical care.”
We disagree with defendants’ narrow characterization of
plaintiff’s habeas corpus petition and his arguments on
appeal.2 Plaintiff alleged that he has not been provided with
a number of necessary treatments and accommodations,
including medication, mental health counseling, an audio
player to treat his PTSD, and a single cell to manage his
uncontrolled bowel condition and PTSD. When we consider
the allegations in the petition as a whole in the light most
favorable to plaintiff, as our standard of review requires us
to do, those allegations do not merely allege that plaintiff
2
Although plaintiff’s brief on appeal focuses on his uncontrolled bowel condition and corresponding request for single cell housing, we do not understand
plaintiff to have abandoned his allegations regarding his other medical needs;
the brief on appeal also points to those other allegations and asserts that those
allegations, when viewed under the standard established in Billings, state a
claim. In any event, the applicable standard of review requires us to consider the
allegations in the petition as a whole to assess whether those allegations state a
claim under Article I, section 16, and the Eighth Amendment.
564 Durham v. Laney
has been denied a single cell; they allege that plaintiff has
a number of serious medical conditions for which needed,
long-term treatment was abruptly stopped. Thus, contrary
to defendants’ arguments on appeal, the petition does allege
that defendants are not providing plaintiff with necessary
medical treatment and does not merely allege that defendants are failing to provide him with a single cell.
For the foregoing reasons, plaintiff’s allegations are
legally sufficient to support a claim for medical habeas relief,
and we must reverse the grant of defendants’ motion to deny,
and remand for further proceedings so that the parties can
develop the evidence related to plaintiff’s allegations.
Reversed and remanded.