Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

309 Or. App. 589

State v. Preusse

Court of Appeals of Oregon

Decided March 3, 2021

Court of Appeals of Oregon · decided 2021-03-03

Remanded for resentencing · Decided 2021-03-03

                                   589

   Submitted July 2, 2020; remanded for resentencing, otherwise affirmed
                              March 3, 2021


                   STATE OF OREGON,
                    Plaintiff-Respondent,
                              v.
                 KEVIN PATRICK PREUSSE,
                    Defendant-Appellant.
                 Marion County Circuit Court
                    17CN05561; A170398
                               
482 P3d 189


   Donald D. Abar, Judge.
    Ernest G. Lannet, Chief Defender, and Rond Chananudech,
Deputy Public Defender, Office of Public Defense Services,
filed the brief for appellant.
   Ellen F. Rosenblum, Attorney General, Benjamin Gutman,
Solicitor General, and Christopher Perdue, Assistant Attorney
General, filed the brief for respondent.
  Before Armstrong, Presiding Judge, and Tookey, Judge, and
Aoyagi, Judge.
   PER CURIAM
   Remanded for resentencing; otherwise affirmed.
590                                          State v. Preusse

        PER CURIAM
         In this case, defendant challenges the trial court’s
imposition of a special condition of probation that forbade him
to “enter into or participate in any intimate relationship or
intimate encounters with any person (male or female) without prior written [probation officer] approval.” The condition
was imposed for defendant’s punitive-contempt conviction,
after he violated a restraining order that prohibited him
from contacting his former girlfriend. In defendant’s view,
the challenged probation condition was more restrictive
than necessary to accomplish the goal of probation for the
contempt conviction; unconstitutionally overbroad under the
Fourteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution;
and unconstitutionally vague under the Oregon and United
States Constitutions.
         The state concedes that it was error for the trial
court to impose the condition. That is because, although a
trial court has discretion to impose special conditions of probation “for the protection of the public or reformation of the
offender, or both,” ORS 137.540(2), the imposition of special
conditions of probation must be “reasonably related to the
crime of conviction or the needs of the defendant,” 
id.,
 and
“must be supported by the record at trial or at the sentencing hearing,” State v. Gallo, 
275 Or App 868, 869
, 
365 P3d 1154
 (2015). We agree with the state that the record does not
support the challenged special condition of probation and
accept the concession. Consequently, we reverse and remand
with an instruction to remove defendant’s probation condition requiring a probation officer’s permission for defendant
to “enter into or participate in any intimate relationship or
intimate encounters with any person (male or female).”
        Remanded for resentencing; otherwise affirmed.

/309/orapp/589 · .json · Public domain