Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

309 Or. App. 762

State v. Welt

Court of Appeals of Oregon

Decided March 10, 2021

Court of Appeals of Oregon · decided 2021-03-10

Remanded for resentencing · Decided 2021-03-10

                                  762

   Submitted January 27; remanded for resentencing, otherwise affirmed
                            March 10, 2021


                    STATE OF OREGON,
                     Plaintiff-Respondent,
                               v.
                 TYSON CAMERON WELT,
                    Defendant-Appellant.
                 Benton County Circuit Court
                    19CR04873; A170561
                               
483 P3d 56


   David B. Connell, Senior Judge.
   Ernest G. Lannet, Chief Defender, Criminal Appellate
Section, and Sarah De La Cruz, Deputy Public Defender,
Office of Public Defense Services, filed the brief for appellant.
   Ellen F. Rosenblum, Attorney General, Benjamin Gutman,
Solicitor General, and Shannon T. Reel, Assistant Attorney
General, filed the brief for respondent.
  Before Ortega, Presiding Judge, and Shorr, Judge, and
Powers, Judge.
   PER CURIAM
   Remanded for resentencing; otherwise affirmed.
Cite as 
309 Or App 762
 (2021)                                             763

           PER CURIAM
         Defendant appeals from a judgment of conviction
for menacing, interfering with a peace officer, and seconddegree disorderly conduct. Defendant challenges the trial
court’s refusal to give a witness-false-in-part jury instruction and the court’s imposition of special conditions of probation related to drugs and alcohol. We affirm defendant’s
convictions but accept the state’s concession that the trial
court erred in imposing the special conditions of probation
and remand for resentencing.
         We reject defendant’s challenge to the court’s refusal
to give a witness-false-in-party jury instruction, because
defendant failed to preserve the argument he makes on
appeal and does not request that we review for plain error.
Below, defendant told the court that he would be requesting
a witness-false-in-part instruction based on an argument
that testimony of police officers supported the inference
that the victim had lied about not brandishing or grabbing a
firearm that he had on him during the incident with defendant. There was additional discussion in chambers to finalize jury instructions that was not made part of the record,
after which, defendant made the following objection on the
record: “As stated in chambers, I object to the un-inclusion
or dis-inclusion of the witness false in part instruction[.]”
On appeal, defendant argues that the court erred in not
giving the instruction, because “[t]he evidence supported an
inference that [the victim] willfully testified falsely about
whether he told the police that he had a permit to carry
a concealed weapon.” That argument presents a different
basis on which to give the witness-false-in-part instruction,
which it does not appear on the record was presented to the
trial court; accordingly, defendant’s contention on appeal
was not preserved. Also, defendant does not request that we
conduct plain error review. As a result, we reject defendant’s
first assignment of error.
         In his remaining assignments of error, defendant
challenges the imposition of eight special probation conditions related to drugs and alcohol1 when his convictions
    1
      Defendant challenges eight special conditions of probation on appeal which
required defendant to complete a substance abuse evaluation and recommended
764                                                            State v. Welt

were not connected to the use of substances, because those
conditions are not “reasonably related to the crime of conviction or the needs of the probationer for the protection of
the public or reformation of the probationer, or both.” ORS
137.540(2). The state concedes that the trial court erred in
imposing those special conditions of probation. We agree
with and accept the state’s concession and conclude that the
challenged special conditions of probation are invalid. See,
e.g., State v. Borders, 
293 Or App 791
, 
429 P3d 1067
 (2018)
(special probation conditions related to alcohol use did not
meet requirements of ORS 137.540(2) where the crime of
conviction was not connected to the defendant’s alcohol use,
even though the defendant had a history of driving while
intoxicated).
           Remanded for resentencing; otherwise affirmed.




treatment, and prohibited defendant from consuming or possessing alcoholic
beverages, entering establishments where alcohol is the primary sale item, possessing or using controlled substances or intoxicating inhalants, possessing or
using drug paraphernalia, associating with any person known to “use, sell, manufacture, deliver, or possess unlawful controlled substances or narcotics,” being
present at any place “where unlawful controlled substances are used, kept, sold,
grown, manufactured, or distributed,” and serving as a “designated primary care
giver” under the Oregon Medical Marijuana Act.

/309/orapp/762 · .json · Public domain