Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

32 Me. 178

Foster v. Pennington

Supreme Judicial Court of Maine

Decided July 1, 1850

Supreme Judicial Court of Maine · decided 1850-07-01

Exceptions from the District Court in Aroostook county. Assumpsit on an alleged contract to deliver to the plaintiff !í a certain large quantity of oats ; viz. 600 bushels.” The proof was of a contract for 1000 bushels, of which the defendant had delivered 207. The defendant’s counsel objected to the variance; but the Judge instructed the jury, that a contract to deliver 1000 bushels would sustain the declaration. relied on 2 Hill, 126.

Verdict for plaintiff · Decided 1850-07-01

Howard, J.,

¶1orally.—The instruction was erroneous. It made a contract for 1000 bushels to sustain a claim upon one for 600. The videlidt can have no such effect. There was a variance, and it was a material one.

¶2Exceptions sustained.

/32/me/178 · .json · Public domain