Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

32 Me. 192

Cooper v. Bakeman

Supreme Judicial Court of Maine

Decided July 1, 1850

Supreme Judicial Court of Maine · decided 1850-07-01

<p>In replevin, upon a plea of non cepit with brief statement that the property is in the defendant, and not in the plaintiff, it is incumbent on the plaintiff to prove property in himself.</p> <p>If the brief statement merely allege property in the defendant, without denying it to be in the plaintiff, the burden of proving ownership is on the defendant. — Per Wells, J.</p>

Decided 1850-07-01

Wells, J.,

¶1orally.—Under our statute, non cepit with brief statement of property in the defendant and not in the plaintiff, does not admit property in the plaintiff. Such pleading creates substantially an issue on the plaintiff’s property. It is therefore incumbent on the plaintiff to prove property in himself. At common law, in a plea of property in the defendant, the onus is on plaintiff to prove property in himself, because if the issue be found merely that the property is not in the defendant, the plaintiff cannot have judgment. The plaintiff alleges the property to be his. The burden is on him to prove it.

¶2In this case, the Judge ruled that the burden of proof was on the defendant to show property in himself. This was erroneous.

¶3It would have been right, under our statute, if the pleading had not denied property in the plaintiff.

¶4 Exceptions sustained

/32/me/192 · .json · Public domain