Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

34 Ky. 219

Brown v. Calvert

Court of Appeals of Kentucky

Decided June 14, 1836

Court of Appeals of Kentucky · decided 1836-06-14

<p>Assumpsit.</p> <p>From the Circuit Court for Spencer County.</p> <p>Whenever a declaration is so general as not to apprize the defendant of the nature and extent ¡of the demand, he is entitled to a bill of particulars—to which the plaintiff will be restricted ip his proof.</p>

Decided 1836-06-14

Judge Ewing

¶1delivered the Opinion of the Court,

¶2This is an action of assumpsit, brought by Calvert against Brown, with general counts in the declaration. And the only question is—did the Court err in overruling the motion of the defendant for a bill of particulars, made before the trial commenced?

¶3Whenever the form of the declaration is so general, as not to apprize the defendant of the nature, character and extent of the claim set up against him, he may demand a bill of particulars. Such a bill is not only proper, by way of limiting the plaintiff in his proof, to the specific demands claimed by him, but is essential to enable the defendant to prepare fully for his defence, and to guard him against surprise. The right is not only sanctioned by authority, but by reason and propriety. 3 Starkie on Ev. 1054. It was therefore erroneous to overrule the defendant’s motion.

¶4Wherefore, it is considered by the Court, that the judgr ment of the Circuit Court be reversed, and the cause remanded, that a new trial may be granted.

/34/ky/219 · .json · Public domain