Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

346 Pa. 240

29 A.2d 475

Fitzpatrick v. Sheppard

Supreme Court of Pennsylvania

Decided November 24, 1942

Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · decided 1942-11-24

Key passage — most relied on by later courts

““The trial judge submitted the case to the jury which was correctly charged and particularly with respect to the duty and liability of operators of vehicles at intersections. The court correctly charged the jury with respect to the law pertaining to the duty of drivers at traffic controlled intersections. The evidence before the jury for its consideration was the conduct of both the defendant Dixon and the additional defendant Kesselman. The jury found Dixon negligent and exonerated Kesselman. The jury resolved the factual dispute and the charge was free of reversible error. A review of the record indicates Mrs. Sternberg suffered serious and permanent injuries. The verdict of $10,000.00 was inadequate and the court so held and it was warranted in granting a new trial by reason of the inadequacy of the verdict returned for her, she having suffered serious injuries, including multiple fractures and lacerations, resulting in severe pain and permanent disability and disfigurement. However, this is not a proper reason for a retrial of all of the issues previously determined in a trial free of error. The sole reason for granting a new trial was the inadequacy of the verdict. There was ample evidence which proved the accident due to the sole negligence of the defendant Andrew Dixon, and the jury was justified in finding no negligence on the part of Mr. Kesselman. The court committed a clear abuse of discretion in granting a new trial as to the additional defendants who, having been”

quoted by 1 later decision, including Stokan v. Turnbull

“... The plaintiff's position is clear. If she is required to proceed against Sheppard alone she fears that another jury might conclude that the doctor was at fault and Sheppard was not. That, however, is not a legal reason for requiring Dr. McCombs to stand trial again when he has been exonerated by a jury after trial without error.”

quoted by 1 later decision, including 298 So. 2d 518 - Lee County v. Southern Water Contractors, Inc.

Relies on Class & Nachod Brewing Co. v. Giacobello · Bailey v. C. Lewis Lavine, Inc. · Girard Trust Co. v. George v. Cresson Co.

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1942-11-24

How this case has been cited

Cited by 28 later decisions — most recently July 1978 · most notably Frank v. W. S. Losier Co., Inc. (1949), Segriff v. Johnston (1960)

28 state decisions

801942195019601970decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

¶1 Opinion by

Mr. Justice Parker,

¶2 This action in trespass was brought by Mary E. Fitzpatrick against Martha L. Sheppard and Dr. Robert P. *241 McCombs. Shortly after suit was begun Mary E. Fitzpatrick died and her administratrix was substituted as plaintiff. When the case was tried the jury found a verdict against Martha Sheppard and a verdict for the defendant Dr. McCombs. Plaintiff and defendant Martha L. Sheppard filed motions for a new trial. A new trial was granted as to each defendant and Dr. McCombs has appealed from the granting of a new trial as to him.

¶3 At the threshold we are presented with the question as to whether the circumstances are such that an appeal lies. More particularly did the court below in its opinion show “that it would have refused to grant the new trial but for reasons distinctly set forth, which, in its opinion, control the whole case” and did the reasons given involve the consideration of oral evidence? See Class & Nachod Brew. Co. v. Giacdbello, 277 Pa. 530, 121 A. 333.

¶4 The plaintiff was standing on the sidewalk at a street corner when automobiles driven by the defendants, approaching the intersection at right angles to each other, collided and the car of Dr. McCombs was pushed over the curb by the impact where it struck the plaintiff inflicting serious injuries on her from which she died.

¶5 While the sole reason given for granting a new trial was the inadequacy of the verdict, that of itself would not have been sufficient to warrant a review by this court: Class & Nachod Brew. Co. v. Giacobello, supra; Girard Tr. Co. v. George V. Cresson Co., 333 Pa. 418, 422, 5 A. 2d 221. But the court below in its opinion granting the new trial, after showing that the verdict was “shockingly inadequate”, stated: “If it were possible to have a retrial solely of the question of what is a proper sum to compensate for the pain and suffering of the original plaintiff, permitting the general verdict against defendant Sheppard, and the award of damages for expenses and loss of life, to stand, then it would of course be quite proper to leave defendant McCombs out of the picture entirely.”

¶6 *242 We understand that to be a clear statement that except for the one reason assigned a new trial would not have been granted as to the doctor. It is also apparent that the granting of a new trial as to Dr. McCombs did not involve the consideration of any oral or other evidence. This is one. of a class of cases where an appeal will lie from an order of the court below granting a new trial.

¶7 Did the court exceed its legal powers in granting the new trial as to Dr. McCombs? We think it did. The plaintiff’s position is clear. If she is required to proceed against Sheppard alone she fears that another jury might conclude that the doctor was at fault and Sheppard was hot. That, however, is not a legal reason for requiring Dr. McCombs to stand trial again when he has been exonerated by a jury after trial without error.

¶8 The sole reason for granting a new trial had to do with the issue between plaintiff and Sheppard. We must assume, and the appellees have not suggested, anything to the contrary, that the issue between plaintiff and the doctor was tried without error. The consequences of the circumstance that the jury examined the conduct of both defendants in one trial and in doing so erred only in assessing damages as to Sheppard cannot be visited on the doctor. He has a verdict after a fair trial and cannot be deprived of it.

¶9 As forcibly expressed by Mr. Justice Simpson in Cleveland W. Mills Co. v. Myers-Jolesch Co., 266 Pa. 309, 311, 109 A. 662: “If the question or questions decided do not depend on oral evidence, are conclusive of the whole case, and nothing is left but to enter the judgment which their determination requires, we may well reverse an erroneous order granting a new trial; because, in that event, a retrial would be an injustice, antagonistic to the constitutional provision entitling suitors to ‘justice ... without sale, denial or delay’.”

¶10 It is well settled that a new trial may be granted as to defendant Sheppard and refused as to Dr. McCombs: *243 Bailey v. C. Lewis Lavine, Inc., 302 Pa. 273, 278, 153 A. 422; Barker v. Barrett, 145 Pa. Superior Ct. 22, 20 A. 2d 812.

¶11 The order of the court below granting a new trial as to the defendant Dr. Robert P. McCombs is reversed and it is directed that judgment be entered in his favor on payment of the jury fee; and the order of the court below granting a new trial as to defendant Martha L. Sheppard is affirmed.

/346/pa/240 · .json · Public domain