Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

35 Me. 287

Smith v. Porter

Supreme Judicial Court of Maine

Decided July 1, 1853

Supreme Judicial Court of Maine · decided 1853-07-01

On Facts agreed. Debt on a recognizance for debt for $13,39, signed and sealed by James Kimball, and brought against this defendant as his executor. Plea, that this defendant was never executor. In 1849, Kimball, (whose death occurred in 1852,) owned a yoke of oxen, and mortgaged them to secure to one Tilton a note of $15,00. By the terms of the mortgage, Kimball was under no obligation to pay till after a demand.

Cited by 1 later decisions — most recently July 1898

1 state decisions

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1853-07-01

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Rice, J.

¶1— By purchasing the note of Betsey Tilton, with the mortgage of the oxen by which that note was secured, the defendant was subrogated to her rights as mortgagee. This gave him the right to have possession of the oxen, but not to sell them, before the mortgage had been legally foreclosed. Taking possession under his mortgage would not render him liable in this action, for one who takes possession under a fair claim of right is not-chargeable as executor deson tort. Femings v. Garratt 1 Esp. 335.

¶2Nor was the subsequent purchase of the legal and equitable interest that James Kimball’s estate had in the oxen, of Betsey Kimball, the widow of said James, for an apparently full consideration, such an intermeddling with the estate of the deceased Kimball, as would render him liable. The widow, by the sale of the oxen to the defendant, may have rendered *291herself chargeable, as executor in her own wrong, but the party, who, even knowingly, receives goods from an executor de son tort and deals with them as his own, does not himself thereby become an executor de son tort. 9 Ad. & El. 365. There is, however, nothing in this case, to show that the defendant knew that the party of whom he purchased acted without legal authority. A nonsuit is to be entered.

Shepley, C. J., and Wells, Howard and Hathaway, J. J., concurred.
/35/me/287 · .json · Public domain