Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

35 Pa. 59

Roop v. Roop

Supreme Court of Pennsylvania

Decided July 1, 1860

Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · decided 1860-07-01

This was an action of assumpsit by Jacob Hoop, Jr., against Horatio Hoop. The declaration laid the alleged promise by the defendant, to have been made on the first day of March 1857. By reference to the almanac, it appeared that the 1st March 1857 was Sunday.

Cited by 1 later decisions — most recently October 1916

1 state decisions

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1860-07-01

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

¶1The opinion of the court was delivered by

Lowrie, C. J.

¶2The day stated in the declaration is the 1st March 1857, and this is now alleged to be a Sunday, and this is the error assigned in this court. Upon looking at the almanac, we find it to have been Sunday, but we also perceive by the record, that this defence was not suggested or mentioned on the trial; and in fact, that neither were the goods sold on a Sunday, nor was the promise to pay made on that day.

¶3"W e have already decided in several cases, that a mere matter of form, which, if taken advantage of in the court below, would have been cured by an amendment, will not be regarded here: Ward v. Ward, 15 Leg. Int. 83.*

¶4Judgment affirmed.

¶5 Ward v. Ward. In this case, the following opinion was delivered by

¶6Porter, J. — In describing the note in his declaration, the plaintiff missed the date by a year. When the trial came on, the defendant's counsel was prevented from attending. If he had attended and taken the point, an amendment would have been allowed; it is just the case for the exercise of such a power. In this court, we can give him no help, for an objection, curable by amendment, if not made on the trial, is deemed to have been waived: 2 Gasey 333. If the objection had been made there, the later cases would have permitted to cure it here: 11 W. <& S. 365; 5 Harris 173; 10 Id. 89. Whether it were taken or not, the result would be the same; and this is but an instance of the growing disposition of the law to brush aside every formal obstacle in the way of substantial justice. Judgment affirmed.

/35/pa/59 · .json · Public domain