Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

37 Ala. 687

Harrison v. McCrary

Supreme Court of Alabama

Decided June 15, 1861

Supreme Court of Alabama · decided 1861-06-15

Heard beforedbe lion. James B. Clark. This complainant in this case, L. 0. Harrison, and P. ÍL McCrary, the defendant, formed a. mercantile partnership in October, 1851. 5 the business to be conducted in tlie town of Summerfield, in Dallas county, and to continue for the period of five years, unless sooner dissolved by agreement.

Relies on Wiggins v. Armstrong · Hamilton v. Adams · Thomas v. Henderson

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1861-06-15

How this case has been cited

Cited by 7 later decisions — most recently May 1921

7 state decisions

201861187018801890190019101920decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

R. W. WALKER, J.

¶1There was no error in the decree dissolving the injunction. The complainant,admits that he committed a trespass in taking and carrying.away the defendant’s slaves; -.and- he seeks to enj.oin the action for that trespass, -on the ground that the defendant,- is indebted to him on account -of partnership transactions,- and is insol- - v&nf. The well-settled rule, that a creditor at large, or before judgment, is not entitled-to an injunction, to prevent the debtor from fraudulently disposing of his prop---erty, (Wiggins v. Armstrong, 2 Johns. Ch. 144; Mercer v. Downs, Hopkins’ Ch. 305,) would seem to be decisive, against the right to an-injunction in this case. For, if the creditor can take his debtor’s property. by force, to secure his debt, and hold on to it by enjoining, the action of tres- - pass, he is permitted to accomplish by force, sanctioned in-¡ equity, that which the court would not allow him to do without force. To suffer that to be done, would be a plain violation of the familiar and wholesome., principle, that a . right cannot grow out of a wrong. — See, further, Hamilton v. Adams, 15 Ala. 596. In addition to this, a court of law is the proper-tribunal .-to- ascertain the damages, to which a .party is entitled for a trespass.uppn his property. ‘ Smart'.: money,’ or vindictive damages, ean.be recovered at law;-..but a court of equity cannot consider'.that question at all, and therefore cannot ascertain the damages. The effect of'-, sustaining the injunction, in such a case, must be to deny the right of the injured party to smart money.

¶2It is hardly necessary to add, that where á bill does not\>, warrant an;-:inj unction, the injunction may properly be dis- - solved, although th.ej>ill may be retained for.other relief.-r'Norris v. Norris, 27 Ala. 529.

¶3Decree affirmed.

/37/ala/687 · .json · Public domain