Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

39 Pa. 528

Cooper v. Platt

Supreme Court of Pennsylvania

Decided July 24, 1861

Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · decided 1861-07-24

<p>Construction of Bond of Indemnity. — Equitable Substitution not allowed where Claim of Party to whose Right it is ashed, is unsatisfied.</p> <p>A judgment-bond of indemnity by one largely indebted, was given to three, in the sum of $200,000, upon condition to be void “ if the obligor or his heirs, executors, &e., shall pay or cause to be paid, unto the persons holding and owning the notes, drafts, and claims specified on the back thereof, or to their certain attorney, executors, administrators, or assigns, the full sum set opposite thereto on the back thereof, and shall indemnify and save harmless the obligees as sureties or endorsers of said notes, drafts, and claims, and indemnify each of said obligees against all other claims for which they may be liable as sureties of the obligor, and shall furnish obligees with money to meet said claims, to raise which, as well as to secure the obligees, this bond is given,” &c. Among the claims endorsed on the bond, there was a draft which had been drawn by the obligor to the order of one of the obligees, and accepted by T., P. & Co., for accommodation of the drawer, without any consideration and without having any funds of his in hand, which was not known to the obligees. This was held at maturity by McT. & Bro., by whom suit was brought against all the parties, and a judgment recovered, which was paid by P., for the firm of T., P. & Co. No funds were furnished by the obligor to meet this claim, nor were the proceeds of his property realized by the obligees, sufficient to satisfy the claims, to secure which the bond was given. In an action by P. against the obligees, for a pro rata share of the proceeds of the obligor’s property, it was held, that, in discharging the liability of C., the plaintiff aid nothing more than he was legally bound to do, and could not come in by equity on the fund raised by the indemnity bond.</p>

Cited by 1 later decisions — most recently September 1873

1 state decisions

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1861-07-24

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

¶1The opinion of the court was delivered,

by Lowrie, C. J.

¶2The bond of indemnity was to secure Cottrell from liability on his endorsement of Platt’s acceptance, held by McTague, and also to secure Cooper, Cottrell, and Righter on many other endorsements. Now when Platt paid his acceptance, Cottrell was released from his endorsement, and the bond became legally satisfied to that extent. But it appears now that Platt was an accommodation acceptor of the obligor, though that was not known to the obligees till long after the acceptance fell due. Does this fact allow Platt to come in by equity upon the fund raised by the indemnity bond ? Yes, as against the principal debtor; for he had set apart this fund for that debt among others. But is it so as against Cottrell ?

¶3In the case of Eastman v. Foster, 8 Met. 28, it is decided No, in a like case. The bond of indemnity was to secure Cottrell from many liabilities, and from this one he was legally discharged, and Platt was bound to have him discharged, and equity does not allow him to annul that discharge by coming in on the fund while any of the other liabilities of Cooper, Cottrell, and Righter remain unpaid. What would, after these are paid, go back to the debtor, the equitable surety may claim, and nothing more. To hold otherwise would make these endorsers less secure, so far as this draft is concerned, by having taken collateral security, than they would have been without it.

¶4And we may come to the same result in another way. Surely a man may contract for his own individual indemnity, without being required to share it with all other sureties to his own partial disappointment. Especially may he do so when he is liable only on the contingency that the other sureties fail of their duty. Platt, by the very form of the principal contract, was bound to keep Cottrell safe, and therefore he cannot claim to be equal surety with Cottrell, and require him to contribute to the payment of the acceptance. If Cottrell had paid the draft, he would have been the creditor, and, on suing Platt as acceptor, there would have been no defence; but Platt, after paying his acceptance, might have said: “ Here I am a mere surety, and you hold collaterals for this and other debts, and I demand the benefit of any surplus there may be.” Such was his right under *535these contracts. Instead of this, the court below treated Cottrell and Platt as equal sureties, which was contrary to the nature of the transaction.

¶5Judgment reversed, and judgment for the defendant below on the case stated.

/39/pa/528 · .json · Public domain