Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

4 Whart. 358

Henness v. Meyer

Supreme Court of Pennsylvania

Decided April 1, 1839

Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · decided 1839-04-01

An action was brought in this Court to July term, 1838, by John Henness, against John H. Meyer, and a rule of reference entered, on the 5th of September, 1838, under the 8th section of the act of the 16th of June, 1836, “ relating to reference and arbitration.” The arbitrators made an award in the following words : “We do award in favour of the plaintiff #2500; or that the defendant carry out and strictly fulfil his part of the contract.” The defendant filed the following…

Cited by 1 later decisions — most recently December 1882

1 district ·

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1839-04-01

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Per Curiam. —

¶1There is nothing in the exception to the time of the ■ reference. In consolidating the existing laws by the act of 1836, the provision which prohibited a compulsory reference before the return day of the writ, was purposely left out. Nor is it at all certain, that a return day out of term, would not have satisfied the requirements of the exploded section. But the award is vicious on another ground. It is a cardinal requisite of every award, and peculiarly essential to an award of arbitrators, who perform the functions of a jury, that it be not only certain but final; and no counsel would attempt to sustain a verdict, that the defendant pay a sum in numero, “ or carry out and strictly fulfil his part of the contract.” The alternative could not be rejected, because it must be taken for a substantive part of the finding; for who could say that a verdict would have been rendered against the defendant without it 1 Yet it would require a new action and a new finding, to settle the terms of the contract; so that this award is quite as inconclusive as was the verdict in Bugley v. Wallace, (16 Serg. & Rawle, 245,) or in Allen v. Flock, (2 Penn. Rep. 159,) and for this reason the award is erroneous.

¶2Award set aside.

/4/whart/358 · .json · Public domain