Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

41 Me. 507

Small v. Trickey

Supreme Judicial Court of Maine

Decided July 1, 1856

Supreme Judicial Court of Maine · decided 1856-07-01

Osr Report from Nisi Prius, Cutting, J., presiding. Debt on Award. The plea was the general issue, and a brief statement, alleging a want of publication and demand, and that the award was made ex parte. The only question presented and relied on in this case was, whether certain ex parte proceedings by the referees vacated their award. One Cushing was a witness before the referees, and swore to an account of lumber taken from his books, which were not produced at the trial.

Decided 1856-07-01

Appleton, J.

¶1After the parties had introduced such proof as they severally relied upon, and had each presented their views as to the effect of the same, the referees adjourned for *511a final decision. Before the award was made, it was deemed desirable by the referees to verify an account, which had been sworn by a witness to be correct, by comparing the same with the original books of account from which it had been copied. A comparison was made, and the copy was found correct. The party in whose favor the award was made accompanied one of the referees, who made this examination, and aided in making the comparison. This was done for the purpose of preventing any possible mistake. It is not alleged that the comparison was fraudulently or erroneously made. This cannot be regarded in any meaning of the phrase, as an ex parte hearing. No misconduct, partiality or fraud on the part of the referees is shown to exist.

¶2It was held in the House of Lords, in Drew v. Drew, 33 Eng. Law & Eq. 9, that where an arbitrator examines witnesses behind the back o.f one of the parties, such party is justified in at once abandoning the reference and applying to a Judge to rescind the submission; but if he continue, after the fact come to his knowledge, to attend the subsequent proceedings, this will be a waiver of the irregularity, and he cannot afterwards set aside the award on that ground. But in the present case no witnesses were examined, and no evidence was heard. The comparison instituted was a measure of extraordinary precaution on the part of the referees, and for the benefit of the losing party. No error having been discovered, the award was based upon the evidence introduced at the trial, and was entirely unaffected by the subsequent proceeding, to which the defendant objects.

¶3No reason is perceived for taking off the default which has been entered. Default to stand.

Tenney, C. J., and Hathaway, May and Goodenow, J. J., concurred.
/41/me/507 · .json · Public domain