Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

42 Me. 196

Hart v. Hardy

Supreme Judicial Court of Maine

Decided July 1, 1856

Supreme Judicial Court of Maine · decided 1856-07-01

On Exceptions from Nisi Prius, Hathaway, J., presiding. This was an action of assumpsit. The amount claimed was $220,62. The defendant filed his specifications of defence with the clerk of the court for the county of Waldo, as follows:— •“Waldo, ss. — Supreme Judicial Court, Oct. term, 1855. “ Simpson Hart v. Joseph P. Hardy. “ The defendant in this action, says for a defence, that the plaintiff has no claim whatever against him.

Decided 1856-07-01

Tenney, C. J.

¶1This is a case, wherein the defendant appeared and desired a trial, and was required to file with the *197clerk of the court a specification in brief of the nature and grounds of his defence, &c., according to the statute of 1855, c. 174, § 4.

¶2The object of the statute was, undoubtedly, that the other party might be apprised of the obstacles, which would be presented to the maintenance of his suit, in season to be prepared for a trial, without incurring useless expense. More was required than a mere statement, that the plaintiff had no claim. The plea of the general issue, which could be filed at any time before the trial commenced, would indicate all this.

¶3It requires no argument to prove, that the statement, “ the plaintiff has no claim whatever against him,” is not a compliance with the provision of the statute.

¶4Exceptions overruled, judgment on the default.

Hathaway, Appleton and May, J. J., concurred.
/42/me/196 · .json · Public domain