Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

43 Me. 161

Richardson v. Beede

Supreme Judicial Court of Maine

Decided July 1, 1857

Supreme Judicial Court of Maine · decided 1857-07-01

At the trial of this action, which was brought on an annexed account, the defendant offered a receipt purporting to be in full of all demands, which the plaintiff was allowed by the Chief Justice presiding, being a witness for himself, to explain, by stating the circumstances under which it was given.

Decided 1857-07-01

Rice, J.

¶1Assumpsit on an account annexed to the writ.

¶2During the trial the defendant introduced the following receipt from the plaintiff:

¶3Yarmouth, Nov. 6, 1854.

¶4Received of Daniel Beede, Jr., sixty-five dollars in full of all demands. (Signed,) William T. Richardson.

¶5The plaintiff being a witness for himself upon the stand, was asked by his counsel to state the circumstances under. which the receipt was given.

¶6To this the defendant objected, upon the ground that it was not competent for the plaintiff to vary or contradict the written receipt, except to show that it had been obtained by fraud or mistake; but the court overruled the objection and the plaintiff was permitted to testify.

¶7So far as a receipt goes only to acknowledge payment or delivery, it is merely prima facie evidence of the fact, and not conclusive; and therefore the fact which it recites may be contradicted by oral testimony. 1 Greenl. Ev., p. 305.

¶8The case of receipts is an exception to the general rule that- oral testimony is not admissible to contradict or vary a written contract. They may always be explained by oral testimony. Brooks v. White and als., 2 Met., 283; Stackpole v. Arnold, 11 Mass., 27; Johnson v. Johnson, 11 Mass., 359; Rollins v. Dyer; 16 Maine R., 475; Wilkinson v. Scott, 17 Mass., 249.

¶9The fact that this receipt purports to be in full of all demands, does not change the rule. The authorities cited by *163the defendant’s counsel are all adverse to his position on this point.

¶10Exceptions overruled, and judgment on the verdict.

/43/me/161 · .json · Public domain