Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

45 Me. 483

Benner v. Welt

Supreme Judicial Court of Maine

Decided July 1, 1858

Supreme Judicial Court of Maine · decided 1858-07-01

Writ oe Error, brought by Jacob Benner, the second, Isaac Oliver, Lewis Benner, the second, Edward Benner, the second, and Isaac Schwartz, the last three plaintiffs in error sueing by Rufus J. Eeyler, their guardian and next friend, they being minors and under the age of twenty-one years, to reverse a judgment of this Court rendered against them at the January term, 1856, in favor of Matthias Welt, the present defendant in error.

Cited by 1 later decisions — most recently June 1880

1 state decisions

Relies on Richard v. Walton · Arnold, Duncan & others v. Sandford

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1858-07-01

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

¶1The opinion of the Court was drawn up by

Tenney, C. J.

¶2This is a writ of error, to reverse a judgment recovered by Matthias Welt, against the plaintiffs in error in this Court. The errors assigned are that Lewis Benner, 2d, Edward Benner, 2d, and Isaac Schwartz, were *484minors and under the age of twenty-one years, at the time of the rendition of said judgment, and did not answer by their guardian, or next friend, or by a guardian ad litem,, appointed for them by the Court as by law was required, and judgment was illegally rendered against said Jacob Benner, 2d, Lewis Benner, 2d, Isaac Schwartz and Isaac Oliver. The defendant in the present suit pleads in mullo est erratum, without putting in issue any fact alleged in the writ of error.

¶3..The pie am nullo est erratum is in. the nature of a demurrer, putting in issue only such errors as may be shown on the face of the record. Goodridge & al. v. Ross, 6 Met. 487. Therefore the alleged fact that three of the plaintiffs in error were minors - at • the- • time the judgment was rendered,, not being traversed-in'the pleadings, is to be treated as admitted.

¶4If the judgment is reversed as to a portion of the .present plaintiffs, it cannot be affirmed as to the others. Richards & al. v. Walton, 12 Johns. 434; Arnold v. Sandford, 14 Johns. 417.

¶5Exceptions overruled.

Rice, Hathaway, Appleton, May, and -Davis, J. J., concurred. ■
/45/me/483 · .json · Public domain