Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

45 Me. 596

Rounds v. Stetson

Supreme Judicial Court of Maine

Decided July 1, 1858

Supreme Judicial Court of Maine · decided 1858-07-01

Report by Appleton, J. This was an action of trover against the defendant, to recover the value of a cow sold by him, as pound keeper of the city of Bangor. It appeared in evidence that the cow was duly committed to the pound, August 20, 1857. The notices required by the statute were duly given and kept posted three days, from August 20th to August 22d, inclusive.

Cited by 1 later decisions — most recently August 1948

1 state decisions

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1858-07-01

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

¶1The opinion of the Court was drawn up by

Rice, J.

¶2Section 15, of c. 30, R. S. of 1841, provides that, whenever any pound-keeper shall have received any beast committed to pound under the provision of that chapter, he shall forthwith post, and keep posted for three days, at his dwellinghouse and in two other public places in the same town, advertisements, by him subscribed, stating the name of the impounder or finder, the time and cause of impounding, and a brief description of the beast; notifying the owner to pay what is legally and justly demandable, and to take the beast away; and shall give public notice by the town crier, if such there be within the town.

¶3Section 1 of c. 1?, statutes of 1853, provides that, when any beast shall be impounded, and proceedings had in the manner set forth in the 15th and preceding sections of c. 30, R. S., if the forfeiture, damages, fees, charges and costs shall not be paid, or the beast replevied, within ten days after the notice provided in the fifteenth section shall have been given, the pound-keeper shall, without any other process, sell the said beast at public auction, after having posted up in two public places in the town or city where said beast shall be impounded, at least forty-eight hours before the time of sale, notices of the time and place and cause of said sale, in which he shall insert a brief description of the beast, &c.

¶4The principal question, raised by the facts reported in this case, is as to the time within which the owner of the impounded beasts may reclaim them, or, in other words, at *598what time the pound-keeper may lawfully sell them at public auction. ■

¶5The notice, required to be posted and kept posted three days, by § 15, e. 30, R. S., cannot be deemed to have been given, until the said three days shall have fully expired. Ten days are then allowed, within which to pay any forfeiture, damages, fees, charges and costs that may have accrued. A sale cannot lawfully be made until after the expiration of ten days, nor until after having posted up in two public places in the town or city where said beast shall be impounded, at least forty-eight hours before the time of sale, notices of the time and place of sale. This notice cannot be given during the ten days allowed, within which to pay the forfeiture, damages, &c. During that time, which was reduced, by the statute of 1853, from twenty to ten days, the owner has a right to reclaim his beasts, without being subjected to any charge for advertisements for sale. Such, we think, is the natural construction of the words of the statute. But, were the language doubtful, the statute should not be so construed as to incur forfeiture, but the reverse. This statute is penal in its nature. And, in such cases, entire strictness is requisite. Smith v. Gates, 21 Pick. 55.

¶6The sale was premature. Consequently, by the terms of the report, a default must be entered.

Tenney, C. J., Hathaway, Appleton, Cutting, and Goodenow, J. J., concurred.
/45/me/596 · .json · Public domain