Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

49 Pa. 9

Heist v. Baker

Supreme Court of Pennsylvania

Decided February 13, 1865

Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · decided 1865-02-13

<p>What charges on real estate constitute a lien.— What are divested by sheriff’s sale.</p> <p>1. The mere recitation of unpaid purchase-money in a deed, though standing in the channel of the title, does not constitute a lien: but where expressly charged, the lien will be sustained.</p> <p>2. Therefore, where a deed for land contained the proyision “underand subject to the payment of” a sum of money at the decease of a widow, to children named, the purchaser took it subject to the express lien, which being of indeterminate value and intended to run with the land during the life of the widow, was not divested by a sheriff's sale, in her lifetime.</p> <p>S. Hence a subsequent grantee of the land was liable for the amount of the charge, with interest from the death of the widow, at the suit of the guardian of the children entitled.</p>

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1865-02-13

How this case has been cited

Cited by 5 later decisions — most recently November 1927

5 state decisions

201865187018801890190019101920decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

¶1The opinion of the court was delivered, by

Woodward, C. J.

¶2The deed of March 12th 1849, Jacob N. Baker to Elizabeth Gross, contained these words: “ Under and subject nevertheless to the payment of the sum of $932.52, at the decease of the said Elizabeth Gross, unto the above-named Ann Eliza and Rachel Gross, minor children of Samuel Gross, or to their legal representatives.”

¶3According to the cases cited in the argument, as well as according to the reason of the thing, these words created an express lien upon the land for the sum mentioned, which was not divested by the sheriff’s sale, because, during the life of Mrs. Gross, it was a lien of indeterminate value, and was manifestlv intended to run with the land.

¶4*14The ruling of the learned judge is resisted on the authority of Hiester v. Green, 12 Wright 96; but this is the very converse of that case. There there was no express charge upon the land, and here there is. Such is our repugnance to implied or constructive liens that we refused to treat a recitation of unpaid purchase-money as a lien, though standing in the channel of the title, and we desire to be understood as having refused after great consideration of the subject; but where it is expressly charged the lien must be supported. It is the distinction between express and implied liens. Generally debts are not liens upon land inter vivos, and when a party alleges that a particular debt has become a lien, it .is not unreasonable to hold him to some affirmative proof of it, like a judgment, mortgage, or agreement. This excludes all risk of the courts holding that for a lien which the world does not; it excludes, in a w-ord, all the uncertainties of constructive liens, and furnishes a plain, straight path to walk in.

¶5. Conceiving that the judgment below was entirely consistent with Hiester v. Green, as well as other adjudged cases, it is affirmed.

/49/pa/9 · .json · Public domain