Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

500 Pa. 564

459 A.2d 307

Mezvinsky v. Davis

Supreme Court of Pennsylvania

Decided April 26, 1983

Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · decided 1983-04-26

Cited by 2 later decisions — most recently October 1987

2 state decisions

Relies on Smith v. Allwright · Daly v. Hemphill · Tosto v. Pennsylvania Nursing Home Loan Agency

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1983-04-26

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

ZAPPALA, Justice,

¶1concurring.

¶2I concur in the determination that 42 Pa.C.S.A. § 3133 is unconstitutional. The Commonwealth Court was constitutionally mandated in 1968, Pa. Const. Art. 5, § 4, as a part of the unified judicial system, Pa. Const. Art. 5, § 1. The implementing legislation necessary to create the court, Act of January 6, 1970, 1969 P.L. 434, No. 185, provided a method of gubernatorial appointment of the initial seven judges in a manner guaranteeing minority party representation on the Court. The legislative history of the Act, however, is totally void of any basis, for continued minority party representation. The constitutional provision prescribing the manner of election of judges, Pa. Const. Art. 5 § 13(a) makes no distinction among the statewide courts. I think it is abundantly clear that according to the constitution the manner of election of judges to the Commonwealth Court is to differ in no way from the manner of election of the members of the other courts of this Commonwealth, thus retaining the integrity of a unified judicial system. The *570attempt by the legislature in Section 3133 to carry the minority party representation “guarantee” of the initial appointment over to later elections runs contrary to the constitutional mandates of Art. 5, Sections 1, 4, arid 13, and is an infririgement on the independence of the judiciary.

¶3Without disputing the merits of the plurality’s discussion of the integrity of the judiciary and the irrelevance of party politics to judicial decision making, I find such discussion unnecessary to the decision of this matter.

ROBERTS, Chief Justice,

¶4dissenting.

¶5By arbitrarily discarding recent precedent and substituting its judgment for the considered judgment of the Legislature, the majority “bring[s] adjudications of this tribunal into the same class as a restricted railroad ticket, good for this day and this train only.” Smith v. Allwright, 321 U.S. 649, 669, 64 S.Ct. 757, 766, 88 L.Ed. 987 (1944) (Roberts, J., dissenting). I must dissent.

¶6An enactment of the Legislature may not be declared unconstitutional “unless it clearly, palpably, and plainly violates the Constitution.” Tosto v. Pennsylvania Nursing Home Loan Agency, 460 Pa. 1, 16, 331 A.2d 198, 205 (1975), quoting Daly v. Hemphill, 411 Pa. 263, 271, 191 A.2d 835, 840 (1963). In 1979, this Court upheld the constitutionality of 42 Pa.C.S. § 3133, the statutory provision challenged in this proceeding. Thiemann v. Allen, 485 Pa. 431, 402 A.2d 1348 (1979). In the four years since this Court’s determination of constitutionality there has been no constitutional or statutory change which justifies the majority’s reaching a contrary result. Indeed, only three weeks ago the constitutionality of section 3133 was sustained by the United States District Court for the Middle District of Pennsylvania in a case in which petitioner Mezvinsky was permitted to intervene and presented arguments similar to those advanced here. Orloski v. Davis, 564 F.Supp. 526 (1983).

¶7Although the opinion of Mr. Justice Flaherty perceives that the challenged statute “erodes” “[t]he guarantee of participation in selection of judgeships,” the legislative judg*571ment embodied in section 3133 in fact furthers the legitimate goal of promoting the elector’s exercise of his franchise. The statutory provision not only encourages bipartisan participation but also discourages the practice of “weighted” voting, the casting of only a single vote in order to enhance a single candidate’s chances of success, and thus advances the likelihood that the candidates chosen will have the backing of a substantial portion of the electorate.

¶8As 42 Pa.C.S. § 3133 is as legitimate an exercise of the Legislature’s authority to regulate the electoral process today as it was four years ago, when the constitutionality of the statute was sustained, section 3133 should again be sustained, and the petition for review denied.

McDERMOTT and HUTCHINSON, JJ., join in this dissenting opinion.
/500/pa/564 · .json · Public domain