Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

60 Me. 340

Harding v. Hagar

Supreme Judicial Court of Maine

Decided July 1, 1872

Supreme Judicial Court of Maine · decided 1872-07-01

On exceptions. Assumpsit to recover two and one-half per cent commissions for chartering two ships belonging to the defendant, of 889 and 756-nnr tons respectively, to the U. S. government, in Dec. 1864, for the transportation of hay.

Cited by 2 later decisions — most recently February 1964

1 state decisions

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1872-07-01

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Kent, J.

¶1It is not denied that the plaintiff was a commercial broker within the definition given in U. S. statute of 1864, c. 173, §79, art. 14, as his business was ‘to negotiate freight, and other business for the owners of vessels.’ Such broker was required to pay twenty dollars for a license. By § 73 it is made a highly penal offense for any person, of whom a license is required, to do any act ‘ for the exercising, carrying on, or doing of such business, trade, or profession, without taking out such license.’

¶2The plaintiff sues to recover payment for such acts. It is too well settled to require the citation of authorities; that no party can recover for acts or services done in direct contravention of an express statute, or for property so sold and delivered. When the case develops such forbidden acts, unless protected by a license or authority, it is incumbent on the plaintiff to show such license. ‘ Otherwise,’ as stated by the defendant’s counsel, in his brief, ‘ he comes into court avowing acts, which, done without a license, are prohibited, as the basis of his action, and recovers without proof of the fact necessary to make them lawful.’ State v. Whittier, 21 Maine, 341; State v. Crowell, 25 Maine, 171; State v. Churchill, *34225 Maine, 306; Morgan v. Ruddock, 1 Harr. & Wollaston (Eng. K. Bench), 505.

¶3Exceptions sustained.

¶4New trial granted.

Appleton, C. J.; Walton, Dickerson, Barrows, and Daneorth, JJ., concurred.
/60/me/340 · .json · Public domain