Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

612 Pa. 183

30 A.3d 426

Commonwealth v. Hanible

Supreme Court of Pennsylvania

Decided October 19, 2011

Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · decided 2011-10-19

Cited by 45 later decisions — most recently November 2024 · most notably Commonwealth v. Busanet (2012), Commonwealth v. Mason, L., Aplt (2015)

44 state decisions

Relies on Commonwealth v. Smith

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 2011-10-19

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Justice SAYLOR,

¶1dissenting.

¶2According to the majority opinion, it is undisputed that trial counsel performed incompetently relative to one of the two phases of Appellant’s capital trial (ie., penalty). See Majority Opinion, op. at 438. As to the other phase, Appellant reports that counsel has been uncooperative in the post-conviction investigation. Nevertheless, the case is being disposed of without a factual hearing.

¶3In approving such treatment, the majority applies the review standard subsuming consideration of whether the disposition is supported by the record. See Majority Opinion, op. at 438. It bears repeating, however, that there simply is no evidentia-ry record concerning Appellant’s extra-record claims, such as those of deficient attorney stewardship, since he was denied a post-conviction hearing.

¶4My thoughts concerning the appropriate treatment and frame of reference for appellate review of these dismissals have been set out at length elsewhere. See, e.g., Commonwealth v. Smith, — Pa. -, -, 17 A.3d 873, 915-17 (2011) (Saylor, J., dissenting). I respectfully dissent here, as well, in favor of an evidentiary hearing.

/612/pa/183 · .json · Public domain