Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

62 Me. 443

Morse v. Morse

Supreme Judicial Court of Maine

Decided July 1, 1874

Supreme Judicial Court of Maine · decided 1874-07-01

On exceptions. At tbe December term, 1871, tbis action, brought to recover possession of certain premises in Bath, was referred to Hon. Bufas P. Tapley, the justice presiding, who heard the parties and permitted the tenant to file a paper' in the nature of a disclaimer.

Decided 1874-07-01

Barrows, J.

¶1The referee in his report submits no question of law to the court. He decides the ease both as to law and fact, and awards costs as he thought fit, and as he had the right to do. The report had been once recommitted on the defendant’s motion in order to ascertain whether the award as to costs had been designedly made, or was the result of some clerical error; but the referee distinctly and positively re-afiirms it; and the mere fact. *445that he states upon a loose sheet (returned with the report and the other papers in the case, but not made part of the report) some propositions relating to the law of the case will not avail to impose upon the court the duty of revising his decision.

¶2The presiding judge properly excluded this memorandum. The award is peremptory and there is nothing to show that the referee designed to have its acceptance depend upon the concurrence of the court in the view which he took of the law.

¶3It is by no means apparent that the defendant has any equitable cause of complaint. It would rather seem that his disclaimer of any portion of the demanded premises came so late that the referee was of the opinion that it ought not to affect the plaintiff’s right to costs. . Exceptions overruled.

Appleton, C. J., Dickerson, Danforth and Yirgin, JJ., concurred.
/62/me/443 · .json · Public domain