Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

68 Me. 195

Hardy v. Tilton

Supreme Judicial Court of Maine · decided 1878-05-08

On exceptions. Case against the sheriff for the misfeasance of his deputy, Jeremiah J. Walker, in not paying over money collected on an execution.

Relies on Wilder v. Bailey · Dubois v. Dubois · Clymer v. Willis

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1878-05-08

How this case has been cited

Cited by 3 later decisions — most recently January 2004

1 federal appellate · 2 state decisions

1018781880189019001910192019301940195019601970198019902000decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Walton, J.

¶1The question is whether an officer, who has collected money on an execution, can apply it in satisfaction of another execution against the person for whom it was collected, both executions being in his hands for collection at the same time.

¶2We think not. The attempt has often been made to attach or levy upon money thus situated; but it has uniformly been held *196that money, while in the hands of an officer, who has collected it under legal process, is in custodia legis, and not the subject of attachment or levy.

¶3The leading case in this country was decided by the supreme court of the United States, as long ago as 1801. A sheriff having collected money on an execution, levied thereon an execution which he held against the person for whom the money was collected. The court held that the levy could not legally be made. Turner v. Fendall, 1 Cranch. 117.

¶4Many similar decisions have been made by the state courts. Willes v. Pitkin, 1 Root, (Conn.) 47. Prentiss v. Bliss, 4 Vermont, 513. First v. Miller, 4 Bibb, (Kentucky) 311. Dubois v. Dubois, 6 Cow. 494. Reddick v. Smith, 4 Illinois, 451. Dawson v. Holbrook, 1 Ohio, 135. Crane v. Freese, 1 Harrison, (N. J.) 305. Conant v. Bicknell, 1 D. Chipman, (Vt.) 50. Farmers' Bank v. Beaston, 7 Gill & Johnson, (Md.) 421. Jones v. Jones, 1 Bland, (Md.) 443. Blair v. Cantey, 2 Speers, (S. C.) 34. Burrell v. Letson, 1 Strob. (S. C.) 239. Clymer v. Willis, 3 Cal. 363. Reno v. Wilson, Hemp. (Ark.) 91. Dawson v. Holcomb, 1 Hammond, (Ohio) 275. Wilder v. Bailey, 3 Mass. 289. Thompson v. Brown, 17 Pick. 462.

¶5Some of these cases relate to attempts to attach the money on writs; others to efforts to reach it by trustee process; others, where, as in this ease, attempts were made to levy executions upon it; but the same principle runs through them all; namely, that money collected by an officer on legal process, while it remains in his hands, is to be regarded as in custodia legis, and not the subject of levy or attachment in any form.

¶6Exceptions overruled.

Appleton, C. J., Dickerson, Barrows, Danrorth and Peters, JJ., concurred.
/68/me/195 · .json · Public domain