Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

69 Ala. 189

McCullough v. Flournoy

Supreme Court of Alabama

Decided December 15, 1881

Supreme Court of Alabama · decided 1881-12-15

Heard before Hon. John A. Foster. This was a bill in equity filed by the appellee, an attorney, seeking to establish and enforce a lien on land of his client for services rendered by him as solicitor, in successfully prosecuting-a suit in said Chancery Court, which resulted in a decree divesting the title to the land out of the respondent in that suit, and vesting it in his client.

Cited by 3 later decisions — most recently March 1918

3 state decisions

Relies on Ducat v. City of Chicago · Hanger v. Fowler · Benjamin Cozzens v. Elijah Whitney Et Ux.

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1881-12-15

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

BBICKELL, C. J.

¶1The single question this case presents— whether a solicitor, successfully prosecuting a suit in equity to establish the title of his client to real estate, has a lien on the estate for his fees — was decided in Hinson v. Gamble, 65 Ala. 605. The existence of such a lien is recognized in Tennessee, but it is repudiated in other States. — Hunt v. McClanahan, 1 Heisk. 503; Brown v. Bigley, 3 Tenn. Ch. 618; Humphrey *190v. Browning, 48 Ill. 176; Smalley v. Clark, 22 Vermont, 598; Cozzens v. Whitney, 3 R. I. 79; Hanger v. Fowler, 20 Ark. 667. It seems to us unwarranted by principle to extend the lien of an attorney or solicitor to lands, which have been the subject of .suit. There would be much of difficulty and confusion resulting from it, embarrassing alienation it is the policy of the law to unfetter.

¶2The decree of the chancellor must be reversed, and a decree will be rendered, dismissing the bill, at the costs of the appellee in this court, and in the court of chancery.

/69/ala/189 · .json · Public domain