Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

714 S.W.2d 158

Commonwealth v. Batchelor

Court of Appeals of Kentucky

Decided July 11, 1986

Court of Appeals of Kentucky · decided 1986-07-11

Cited by 1 later decisions — most recently February 1997

1 state decisions

Applies KY 514 § 514.130

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1986-07-11

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

HAYES, Chief Judge:

¶1The sole issue to be resolved in this appeal is whether the Commonwealth is entitled to retain control over property which may be subject to forfeiture under the penal code until proceedings against the individual charged have been completed. We are convinced that the Commonwealth may hold such property pending resolution of the underlying criminal charges and upon conviction subject the property to forfeiture.

¶2The circuit judge in this case ordered the return of a 1977 Ford van and $4,100 in cash to an individual awaiting trial on a charge of receiving stolen property over $100. Stolen property and the large amount of cash were being transported in the van when its driver was stopped and arrested for driving under the influence. He was later charged with knowingly receiving stolen property. After a brief hearing on defendant’s motion, the trial judge ordered the return of the van and the cash.

¶3The Commonwealth argues, and we agree, that the intent of the legislature in enacting the forfeiture statutes could be easily thwarted if one accused of a crime is allowed to regain control over property subject to forfeiture pending the outcome of proceedings against him.

¶4Here, we believe the Commonwealth established a sufficient nexus between the property seized and the criminal activity charged to retain the property until final disposition. Any hardship suffered by the defendant is balanced by the clear legislative mandate requiring forfeiture of property used in furtherance of an offense (KRS 514.130) or proceeds gained by virtue of a violation of the penal code (KRS 500.-090). The hardship is no greater than if the property were seized as evidence.

¶5The judgment of the Kenton Circuit Court is reversed.

¶6All concur.

/714/sw2d/158 · .json · Public domain