Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

8 Watts 329

Kohl v. Harting

Supreme Court of Pennsylvania

Decided May 15, 1839

Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · decided 1839-05-15

Christian Harting against Simon Kohl. Issue directed by the court of common pleas to ascertain what part of the money, if any, Christian Harting is entitled to, arising from the sheriff’s sale of the real estate sold as the property of David Kohl, upon a judgment and execution at the suit of Frederick Moyer, administrator of Andrew Greiner, deceased. Rebecca Kohl was the owner of the land in regard to which this controversy first arose.

Decided 1839-05-15

Per Curiam.

¶1This case is unprecedented in its circumstances; but the plaintiff has a clear equity, and the question regards the specific nature of his relief. The defendant has become the owner of the land in his own right; but though liable to perform the contract himself, he cannot force the plaintiff to take a title through him, which is not the one for which he bargained. Besides, he refuses to say whether he will convey even on those terms; and the plaintiff, for one of these reasons, or for both, chooses, as he may, to declare the contract at an end. In these circumstances, what would a chancellor do with the fund? By payment of purchase-money, a vendee gets a lien on the legal title of the vendor; and by a judicial sale of it, the price is Substituted for the land, on. the common principle of the Bank of Pennsylvania v. Winger, 1 Rawle 302. The prior lien of the mortgage being out of the way, then, we see nothing to hinder the plaintiff from taking satisfaction in his turn.

¶2J udgment affirmed.

/8/watts/329 · .json · Public domain