Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

8 Watts 78

Humphreys v. Rawn

Supreme Court of Pennsylvania

Decided May 15, 1839

Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · decided 1839-05-15

Andrew Murry, treasurer of Dauphin county, against Charles Carson and Charles C. Rawn, Esq. The defendants became the purchasers of an unseated lot in Portsmouth, from the treasurer at a sale for taxes. May Hum- The defendants moved the court for a rule upon the plaintiffs attorney to file his warrant of attorney by the 20th January, inst.

Relies on Naglee v. Albright

Decided 1839-05-15

¶1The opinion of the Court was delivered by

Huston, J.

¶2The court were mistaken in striking off the judgment in this case and in the reason given for it. If there is any case in which a court can strike off a judgment, it must be a very special case, as of fraud or perjury, or of a judgment entered on a cancelled bond, or some such case, and then only where the facts are admitted or established on a trial. The court may open a judgment, or direct an issue to ascertain whether any thing is due, or direct an issue to decide who is entitled to the money, where that is disputed.

¶3If a person shows or proves a right to land, he cannot be called upon to prove a negative and impossibility—if so, no man could .prove it, and no person could recover in ejectmeut.

¶4That May Humphreys did not pay the taxes is evidence, sometimes, of negligence, and where there is an actual adverse possession, may be evidence of abandonment—but in a much stronger case, and one in which an adverse claimant had paid the taxes twenty years or more on a vacant lot, the plaintiff recovered on a title forty years old, there never having been any actual adverse possession. 4 Whart. 294.

¶5The judgment must be restored, and if the defendants can lay any ground for it, the court of common pleas may direct an issue as to the right of May Humphreys to this money. There is not on this record any colour of reason why the defendants should not pay.it to whoever is the owner.

/8/watts/78 · .json · Public domain