Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

8 Watts & Serg. 67

Defraunce v. Brooks

Supreme Court of Pennsylvania

Decided September 15, 1844

Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · decided 1844-09-15

This was an action of ejectment by Robert A. Defraunce and others against William Brooks and Charles Woods. The plaintiffs, who claimed as the heirs of James Defraunce deceased, offered in evidence the following article of agreement, the execution whereof was duly proved: May 27th, 1823.

Relies on 2 Serg. & Rawle 498 - Dearth v. Williamson

Decided 1844-09-15

Per Curiam.

¶1The Judge made a palpable error in applying the rule which requires an express limitation to heirs in a fee-simple conveyance of the legal estate to an executory agreement, which is a conveyance only in equity. This rule, purely technical as it is, and founded in a policy which has disappeared with the feudal system, from which it sprung, is relaxed in many cases even at law.. In executory contracts, equity supplies words of inheritance, and implies a fee where the consideration evinces that not less than a fee was intended. These contracts, like a will, are interpreted so as to give effect to the intention. In Dearth v. Williamson, (2 Serg. & Rawle 498), a covenant to make a lawful deed of conveyance was understood, from the nature of the transaction, to be a covenant to make a good title. On the same principle, a covenant to divide a tract by giving one of the parties a portion of it in recompense of an improvement, must be deemed a covenant to give it out and out. Improvement is a permanent benefit, and compensation of it follows its nature. What is the value of an estate for life in wild land ? Next to nothing. Agree*69ments of compromise, for the sake of repose, are necessarily perpetual where their duration is not limited expressly or by implication. The owner of this title agreed to give a part of the land; and he agreed to give it as he would a chattel; of course he agreed to give it in fee-simple.

¶2Judgment reversed, and a venire de novo awarded.

/8/wattsserg/67 · .json · Public domain