Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

83 Ind. 599

Murphy v. Patterson

Indiana Supreme Court

Decided May 15, 1882

Indiana Supreme Court · decided 1882-05-15

<p>From the Wabash Circuit Court.</p>

Decided 1882-05-15

Niblack, J.

¶1This action was commenced before a justice of the peace. The complaint was by Levi Patterson and William Patterson against Reuben Murphy, on an order' in writing drawn by one Calvin J. Rantz, ■on the 5th day of October, 1878, in favor of the plaintiffs, upon the defendant, for forty dollars, and alleged to have been accepted by the defendant.

¶2There was a judgment before the justice in favor of the plaintiffs, and upon an appeal to the circuit court the plaintiffs again had judgment, for fifty-two dollars.

¶3Error is assigned here upon the alleged insufficiency of the complaint and upon the refusal of the court to grant a new trial.

¶4The first question with which we are confronted in this case is one of jurisdiction. The amount in controversy at the trial, exclusive of interest and costs, was, as has been seen, less than fifty dollars. In such a case an appeal does not lie to this court, the action having originated before a justice of the peace. Acts 1879, p. 168; Galbreath v. Trump, ante, p. 381.

¶5This appeal is, therefore, dismissed, at the costs of the appellants.

/83/ind/599 · .json · Public domain