849
Argued and submitted December 20, 2019, affirmed January 23, petition for
review allowed in part May 28, 2020 (366 Or 490)
See later issue Oregon Reports
STATE OF OREGON,
Plaintiff-Respondent,
v.
PETER ANTHONY CIRAULO,
Defendant-Appellant.
Douglas County Circuit Court
17CR72865, 18CR39718;
A168211 (Control), A168227
459 P3d 960
Kathleen E. Johnson, Judge.
Kyle Krohn, Deputy Public Defender, argued the cause
for appellant. Also on the briefs was Ernest G. Lannet,
Chief Defender, Criminal Appellate Section, Office of Public
Defense Services.
Beth Andrews, Assistant Attorney General, argued the
cause for respondent. On the brief were Ellen F. Rosenblum,
Attorney General, Benjamin Gutman, Solicitor General,
and Daniel Norris, Assistant Attorney General.
Before Ortega, Presiding Judge, and Shorr, Judge, and
James, Judge.
PER CURIAM
Affirmed.
850 State v. Ciraulo
PER CURIAM
In this consolidated criminal appeal, defendant
appeals from two judgments of conviction (Case Nos.
17CR72865 and 18CR39718). Defendant raises five assignments of error. We write to address in summary terms
only defendant’s third and fourth assignments of error.1 As
we discuss below, we reject those assignments and, consequently, affirm the judgments.
In his third and fourth assignments, defendant
assigns error to the trial court’s inclusion of the following
text in the judgments:
“The court may increase the total amount owed by adding collection fees and other assessments. These fees and
assessments may be added without further notice to the
defendant and without further court order.
“…
“Payment of the fines, fees, assessments, and/or attorney’s fees noted in this and any subsequent Money Award
shall be scheduled by the clerk of the court pursuant to
ORS 161.675.”
Defendant contends that ORS 161.675(1) and ORS 1.202(1)
prohibited the court from adding those provisions to the
judgments because the court did not find that defendant had
the ability to pay the fines assessed in his cases. Defendant
further contends that, after entry of the judgments, the
clerk of the court imposed collection fees in violation of ORS
161.675(1).
Regarding defendant’s legal argument challenging
the text of the judgments, we rejected an identical argument in State v. Saunders, 298 Or App 291, 292-93,
447
P3d 60 (2019), and State v. Lord,
301 Or App 653, 657,
458
P3d 701 (2020). Regarding defendant’s factual contention
that the clerk has violated the law by adding collection fees
post-judgment, we recently stated that, to the extent that
1
We reject without further written discussion defendant’s remaining assignments of error. This includes our rejection of defendant’s fifth assignment of error,
raised in supplemental briefing, that contends that the trial court erred in Case
No. 17CR72865 when it instructed the jury that it could return a nonunanimous
verdict.
Cite as 301 Or App 849 (2020) 851
defendant has evidence that the clerk is violating the law
post-judgment, an appropriate course may be for defendant
to challenge the clerk’s actions in the trial court, through
a writ of mandamus, or otherwise. Lord,
301 Or App at
657 n 5; see also ORS 1.025(3) (stating that, where a duty
is imposed by law on a clerk or judicial officer, that duty
“may be enforced by writ of mandamus”); ORS 161.675(3)
(stating that “[a] schedule of payments shall be reviewed by
the court upon motion of the defendant at any time, so long
as the obligation remains unsatisfied”). We, therefore, reject
defendant’s third and fourth assignments of error.
Affirmed.